Michał Suski

LLM Mastery 2026 · Chiang Mai

Who writes the list?

We read 201,534 self-promo listicles cited in AI answers. What gets a list cited is often what keeps your brand from being named. Here are the slides, the data and a playbook for both.

Michał Suski on stage at LLM Mastery 2026 in Chiang Mai, presenting the title slide “Who writes the list?” to a full room

Slides

The full talk, 55 slides

Use the arrow keys or swipe. Each slide comes with the line I said on stage.

Slide 1: Who writes the list? Story by Michał Suski
1 / 55I’m Michał from Surfer, and today we’re talking about the page every brand has and nobody likes to admit to.
Slide 2: Guess who’s #1 on the list: a self-promo “Best X tools” page
2 / 55Hands up if you have a “Best X tools” page with yourself at number one. Does AI fall for it?
Slide 3: Two studies, one question
3 / 55Two studies: 238.6 million citations to see how lists perform, and 201,534 self-promo pages to see what the best ones do differently.
Slide 4: Two kinds of lists: self-promo and third-party
4 / 55There’s the list you write about yourself, and the list somebody else writes about you.
Slide 5: Two ways a list can win: the page gets cited or your brand gets named
5 / 55A list can win in two ways: the page gets cited, or your brand gets named. Keep those apart, because the whole talk hangs on it.
Slide 6: Four acts
6 / 55Four questions: is a list still worth writing, what are the two scoreboards, how to get cited, how to get named.
Slide 7: Act I: Is a list still worth writing?
7 / 55You’ve heard that AI stopped citing lists. Is a list still worth writing?
Slide 8: Lists aren’t losing ground: own and third-party list share by month
8 / 55Everyone says AI stopped citing lists — but on the same reports, the share of both kinds barely moved all year.
Slide 9: A cited list gets you named: 73% vs 57%
9 / 55Take one prompt and ask it again and again: some answers cite your own list, some don’t. When they cite it, your brand shows up in about 15 of 20 answers; when they don’t, in 11 of 20. Same prompt, same engine, same month, so the only difference is the citation.
Slide 10: Your list lifts your rivals too
10 / 55The catch: every competitor you put on your list gets a lift too, almost 4 points each.
Slide 11: On their list, everyone gains: +6.3 pp vs +5.7 pp
11 / 55On someone else’s list it’s the same story: you gain 6.3 points when it’s cited — and every competitor next to you gains 5.7.
Slide 12: Pick your rivals. Fight for #1.
12 / 55If every rival on the list gains almost as much as you do, then who you put on it is a decision, and where you sit on everyone else’s list is the fight.
Slide 13: Lists aren’t losing ground, and a cited one still lifts you
13 / 55Lists aren’t losing ground, and a cited list still pays, so the real question is how to write one.
Slide 14: The page fades, the name stays: citation frequency vs mentions over 11 weeks
14 / 55Eleven weeks in, the page is cited at a quarter of its first-month rate, but your name is still there at 83%.
Slide 15: Act II: Two scoreboards
15 / 55Now the core of the talk: two scoreboards, and they don’t agree.
Slide 16: Best 5% vs worst 5%, in every report (method, step 1)
16 / 55We only compared pages competing for the same answers: same report, same niche, same prompts.
Slide 17: Best 5% vs worst 5%, in every report (method, step 2)
17 / 55In each report we took the best 5% and the worst 5% of pages, once by citations and once by mentions.
Slide 18: Best 5% vs worst 5%, in every report (method, step 3)
18 / 55Then we checked 190 factors on every page: URL, HTML, text, an AI detector and an LLM content rubric.
Slide 19: Best 5% vs worst 5%, in every report (method, step 4)
19 / 55And we backed it with correlations across 426,000 page-report pairs; in data this noisy, 0.1 holding across 5,000 reports is a real signal.
Slide 20: Citations cost you mentions: factors that flip sign
20 / 55Here’s the headline: 20 factors flip sign between the two scoreboards.
Slide 21: Long lists get you cited: 11 vs 8 brands
21 / 55The strongest factor for citations is simply more brands on the list: 11 versus 8 on the most-cited pages.
Slide 22: Short lists get you named: 50% vs 34%
22 / 55And it’s the same factor that pushes your own name out: with 1–2 brands on the list the publisher is named 50% of the time, with 8+ only 34%.
Slide 23: Number of brands on the list: 9 on your own, 18 on theirs
23 / 55Your own list names about 9 brands; the lists other people write about you name about 18.
Slide 24: 47% of citations to third-party lists go to lists with 26+ brands
24 / 55And almost half of the citations to other people’s lists go to lists with 26 or more brands.
Slide 25: AI writing gets cited, not named
25 / 55AI-written pages are more common among the most-cited pages and less common among the pages whose brand gets named.
Slide 26: Getting your list cited and getting your brand mentioned are two different games
26 / 55Getting your list cited and getting your name said are two different games.
Slide 27: Meme: my page got cited 40 times, they said my name once
27 / 55Be honest, which one do you actually want?
Slide 28: Why not both?
28 / 55Or you stop choosing and press both: one long list for citations, a few tight “X vs Y” pages for your name. Hold that thought, we’ll build both.
Slide 29: Act III: Factors to get the page cited
29 / 55Playbook one: how to get the page cited.
Slide 30: A citation opens the door: 57% → 73%
30 / 55Why chase citations at all? Because when AI cites your list, the same answer names your brand 73% of the time instead of 57%.
Slide 31: Scannable lists get cited
31 / 55The most-cited pages are easy to scan and packed with options.
Slide 32: Tables and bold verdicts
32 / 55Concretely, the most-cited lists have a 30-cell table and the least-cited have none.
Slide 33: Less prose, no sales lines
33 / 55Less wall of text, and no sales lines, because CTAs hurt.
Slide 34: Answer first, say who it’s for
34 / 55They answer the question up front and say who the product is for: 96% versus 80%.
Slide 35: Add sources and numbers
35 / 55Back every entry with an expert or a number.
Slide 36: Only tables win and keep citations
36 / 55But winning a citation isn’t keeping it, and the only structure factor that does both is tables.
Slide 37: Tables keep it cited
37 / 55The pages that stay cited have more tables and no year in the URL.
Slide 38: More options. More structure. Answer first.
38 / 55To get cited, make the list easy to lift: more options, more structure, answer first.
Slide 39: Act IV: Factors to get your brand named
39 / 55Playbook two: how to get your own name said. One caveat up front: well-known brands get named more anyway, which is why we compare within a report.
Slide 40: “vs” wins the mention
40 / 55Your title picks the scoreboard: “vs” gets you named, “best” and a year get you cited.
Slide 41: Linked, visual, tight pages get you named
41 / 55The pages that get the publisher named are linked, visual and tight.
Slide 42: Link to your product
42 / 55Eleven internal links versus seven, three images versus one: link to your product and show it.
Slide 43: Avoid fluff: shorter pages and paragraphs
43 / 55They’re also shorter, 2,350 words versus 2,660, so cut before you add.
Slide 44: Title it “X vs Y”, keep pricing off
44 / 55Drop “best”, drop the year, drop the price list.
Slide 45: Checklists won’t get you named
45 / 55The uncomfortable one: the GEO content checklist does nothing for getting you named, and FAQ and key takeaways even hurt.
Slide 46: Write the verdicts yourself
46 / 55What does help is varied wording and fewer template phrases, so write the verdicts yourself.
Slide 47: No year, no ranking: the name sticks
47 / 55Over time it’s the same story: pages with no year and no numbered ranking keep your name in answers longest.
Slide 48: List yourself at #1
48 / 55And the cheapest win in the whole talk: put yourself first. That’s 38% versus 27%, and it costs you no reach.
Slide 49: To get named, write a tighter page that sounds like you and links to you
49 / 55To get named, write a tighter page that sounds like you and links to you.
Slide 50: Two playbooks
50 / 55Two playbooks: one gets the page cited, the other gets your name said.
Slide 51: One page can’t win both. A set can.
51 / 55One page can’t win both, so run a set: one big hub list for citations and a few tight “X vs Y” pages for your name.
Slide 52: Does AI fall for your list?
52 / 55So, back to the question from the start: does AI fall for your list?
Slide 53: Yes, if you target the right scoreboard
53 / 55Yes, if you write it for the right scoreboard.
Slide 54: Thank you
54 / 55Thank you, I’m Michał Suski, and you’ll find me at surfer.ai and msu.ski.
Slide 55: It’s yours: scan for your free AI Visibility Report
55 / 55And one more thing: it’s yours — scan the code for your free AI Visibility Report.

What the data says

Six numbers from the talk

From Surfer AI Tracker data: 238.6M citations across five AI engines and 201,534 self-promo pages.

⅓
of AI citations go to listicles, all year. Your own lists about 11%, other people’s about 23%.
57% → 73%
how often your brand is named when the same prompt cites your own list, compared with when it doesn’t.
+3.7 pp
gained by every competitor you put on your list. On someone else’s list rivals gain almost as much as you.
20
of 190 page factors push citations and brand mentions in opposite directions.
26 vs 83
citation frequency vs brand mentions 11 weeks after the first citation, with the first month at 100.
38% vs 27%
how often you’re named when you list yourself first, compared with when you don’t. Reach stays the same.

The playbook

Pick a goal for each list

One page rarely wins both. Choose what this list is for, then follow that column. Rules marked “Beyond the talk” come from the same data but didn’t make it on stage.

helps hurts. Bars show the effect of following the rule on each scoreboard: the gap between the best and worst 5% of pages in the same niche, where 0.3 means the better page wins about 65% of head-to-heads.

For a hub list that should show up as a source: broad, structured, answer first.

  • List 10 or more options.

    The most-cited lists compare a median of 11 brands, the least-cited 8. The strongest of all 190 factors for citations.

    Cited+0.32
    Named−0.06
  • Put the comparison in a table.

    Median 30 table cells on the most-cited lists, 0 on the least-cited. Tables are also the one structure factor that helps a page keep its citations (27 vs 15 cells after 12 weeks).

    Cited+0.19
    Named−0.04
  • Give every option its own H2, and use H3s inside. Beyond the talk

    More H2s (8 vs 6) and H3s on the most-cited pages.

    Cited+0.20
    Named+0.06
  • Bold a one-line verdict for each option.

    41 bold spans vs 24.

    Cited+0.20
    Named+0.02
  • Move words out of plain paragraphs into lists and tables.

    72.5% of words sit in paragraphs on the most-cited pages, 78.5% on the least-cited. More words inside lists helps too.

    Cited+0.19
    Named+0.06
  • Answer the query in the first lines.

    96% of the most-cited lists answer early, against 80% of the least-cited.

    Cited+0.15
    Named−0.02
  • Say who each option is for.

    95% vs 80%.

    Cited+0.15
    Named−0.03
  • Open with what the page covers and why it matters. Beyond the talk

    An introduction that sets scope (95% vs 83%) and stakes scores higher on the most-cited pages.

    Cited+0.16
    Named−0.04
  • Back every entry with a source, an expert or a number.

    Expert citations 78% vs 64%, relevant statistics 83% vs 72%; attribution quality scores higher too.

    Cited+0.16
    Named−0.03
  • Define terms and make each section stand on its own. Beyond the talk

    Concept definitions, self-contained sections and dense, specific writing all score higher on the most-cited lists. Models lift sections, not pages.

    Cited+0.14
    Named−0.03
  • Show first-hand experience. Beyond the talk

    Pages with experience signals (tested, used, measured) are over-represented among the most-cited lists.

    Cited+0.18
    Named−0.03
  • Cut sales lines and exclamation marks.

    Most-cited pages carry no CTA phrases (median 0 vs 0.13 per 1,000 words). Exclamation marks point the same way.

    Cited+0.15
    Named+0.01
  • “Best” and a year in the title buy reach, not credit.

    Both lean towards citations and away from your brand being named. Use them on a list that plays for reach.

    Cited+0.09
    Named−0.14
  • Keep years and digits out of the URL.

    Pages that keep their citations have a year in the URL less often (11% vs 14%).

  • Plan the refresh.

    11 weeks after its first citation, the median page is cited at about a quarter of its first-month rate; 60% are still cited at all.

  • Aim it at list-seeking prompts. Beyond the talk

    On “best / top / vs / alternatives” prompts, listicles take 49% of third-party citations, against 24% on other prompts.

For a page that should put your name in the answer: short, linked, unmistakably yours.

  • Put yourself at #1.

    Publisher named in 38.4% of answers when listed first, 26.5% when not. Reach doesn’t drop (22.1% vs 20.0% of prompts cite the page).

  • Keep the list short and choose your rivals.

    With 1–2 brands the publisher is named in 50% of citing answers, with 8+ in 34%. Each competitor you add gains about 3.7 points from your list.

    Cited−0.32
    Named+0.06
  • Title it “X vs Y” or by use case.

    “vs” appears on 11% of the most-named pages and 4% of the least-named. “vs” titles credit the publisher in 52.6% of answers, “top” titles in 31.4%.

    Cited−0.04
    Named+0.07
  • Drop “best”, the year and the number from the title.

    “Best” 29% vs 43%, a year 22% vs 36% on the most- vs least-named pages. A number in the title leans the same way.

    Cited−0.09
    Named+0.14
  • Link to your own product pages.

    11 internal links vs 7; 0.77 vs 0.50 links per 100 words. The strongest mention signal in the data.

    Cited+0.14
    Named+0.22
  • Show the product.

    3 images vs 1 (1.5 vs 0.5 per 1,000 words). Screenshots of your own product do the work.

    Cited+0.06
    Named+0.17
  • Cut the page and the paragraphs.

    2,350 words vs 2,660; 29.8 words per paragraph vs 33; 35% short paragraphs vs 30%. Your longest paragraph matters too: keep it under 100 words.

    Cited−0.05
    Named+0.12
  • Keep prices off the list.

    1 price mentioned vs 4.

    Cited−0.04
    Named+0.14
  • Don’t date the page.

    Mentions of 2026 (0 vs 1) and of years in general are lower on the most-named pages.

    Cited−0.08
    Named+0.15
  • Write it yourself.

    63% of the most-named pages are flagged as AI-written, against 75% of the least-named. More words used only once (16.8% vs 15.1%), fewer repeated three-word phrases (11.7% vs 13.2%).

    Cited−0.11
    Named+0.15
  • Skip FAQ blocks, key-takeaways boxes and question-style subheadings. Beyond the talk

    FAQ and key takeaways score lower on the most-named pages (−0.11 and −0.15). Subheadings phrased as questions lean the same way; numbered subheadings too.

    Cited−0.18
    Named+0.15
  • Use a short URL slug. Beyond the talk

    Fewer words and hyphens in the slug on the most-named pages; pages that keep the mention have 4 slug words vs 5.

    Cited−0.06
    Named+0.14
  • Skip the numbered ranking.

    Pages that keep the mention over 12 weeks use an explicit ranking less often (52% vs 62%).

    Cited−0.07
    Named+0.07
  • Talk to the reader, in your own voice. Beyond the talk

    Pages that keep the mention use more “you” (14.6 vs 13.4 per 1,000 words) and more “I/we”.

  • On other people’s lists, fight for the top three.

    Your brand is named in 52% of answers at #1 on someone else’s list, 32% at #5 and 13% from #10 down.

A few things help on both scoreboards, whatever the list is for.

  • Break the text into short paragraphs. Beyond the talk

    Short paragraphs (under 20 words) help on both scoreboards; paragraphs over 100 words hurt on both.

    Cited+0.16
    Named+0.16
  • Link out and link in. Beyond the talk

    Internal links help both citations and mentions; linking to external sources helps too.

    Cited+0.17
    Named+0.18
  • Use H2s, and plenty of them. Beyond the talk

    Pages with H2s, and with more headings per 1,000 words, do better on both scoreboards.

    Cited+0.13
    Named+0.10
  • Run a set of pages, not one page.

    One long hub list for citations, a few tight “X vs Y” pages for your name. That’s our read of the trade-off, not a measured result.

AI instructions

Copy the playbook into your AI writer

Paste into ChatGPT, Claude or your content tool as instructions, fill in the brackets, and go. The audit version checks a list you already have.

You are writing a comparison listicle. The goal: AI answer engines (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, Gemini) cite this page as a source.

These rules come from Surfer's analysis of 201,534 self-promo listicles cited in AI answers (Jul–Sep 2026), comparing the most-cited 5% with the least-cited 5% in the same niche. They describe what the most-cited pages have in common; treat them as strong defaults, not guarantees.

INPUTS
- Target query: [e.g. best project management tools for agencies]
- Our brand: [Brand]
- Options to compare: [list, aim for 10–15]
- Audience: [who is choosing]

STRUCTURE
1. Open with a direct answer in the first 2–3 sentences: the top picks and who each one is for.
2. Right after, say what the page covers and how options were chosen (one short paragraph).
3. Add a comparison table near the top: one row per option, 4–6 columns (best for, key strength, key limitation, a hard fact such as a number or feature).
4. One H2 per option. Use H3s inside for "Best for", "What stands out", "Limitations".
5. Start each option with a one-line verdict in bold.
6. Keep plain paragraphs to under 70% of the words: use bullet lists and the table for facts.
7. Paragraphs: mostly under 20 words, never over 100.

CONTENT
- Compare 10 or more options. Coverage is the strongest citation signal in the data.
- For every option: who it is for, one specific fact, and one statistic or expert source with attribution and a link.
- Define the category and any jargon in one plain sentence each.
- Write each section so it makes sense if quoted on its own (repeat the product name, avoid "as mentioned above").
- Add first-hand evidence where you have it: what was tested, how, with what result.

AVOID
- Calls to action ("sign up", "try it free", "book a demo") and exclamation marks.
- Filler intros and generic conclusions.

TITLE AND URL
- Title pattern: "Best [category] for [use case]" (a year is fine here: this page plays for reach, not for your brand being named).
- Short URL slug, no query parameters, no year or other digits in the URL.

MAINTENANCE
- Citations fade: about 11 weeks after the first citation a page is cited at roughly a quarter of its first-month rate. Schedule a refresh every 6–8 weeks: update facts, keep the table current.

OUTPUT
Return: title, URL slug, meta description (under 155 characters), the opening answer, the comparison table, all sections, and a list of sources with links.
You are writing a comparison page. The goal: when AI answer engines (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, Gemini) answer questions in this category, they name OUR brand.

These rules come from Surfer's analysis of 201,534 self-promo listicles (Jul–Sep 2026), comparing pages whose publisher is named most often with those named least often, in the same niche. They describe what the most-named pages have in common; treat them as strong defaults, not guarantees.

INPUTS
- Our brand: [Brand]
- Main rival(s): [1–3 competitors]
- Use case / audience: [who is choosing and why]
- Our product pages to link to: [URLs]
- Screenshots available: [list]

FORMAT
- Prefer an "X vs Y" page ([Brand] vs [Rival]) or a short use-case comparison.
- Compare 2–5 options in total. Every extra brand on the list is one more name the answer can pick instead of you, and each one gains visibility from your page.
- Put [Brand] first, with a clear, honest reason why.

TITLE AND URL
- Title: "[Brand] vs [Rival]: [the real difference]" or "[Category] for [use case]".
- No "best", no year, no number in the title.
- URL slug: 4 words or fewer.

LENGTH AND RHYTHM
- About 1,500–2,300 words. Cut before you add.
- Average paragraph around 25–30 words, many under 20, none over 100.

LINKS AND MEDIA
- Link to our own product and feature pages throughout: roughly one link per 130 words, at least 10 internal links.
- Include at least 3 screenshots of our product, with descriptive alt text.

VOICE
- Write the verdicts in first person ("we tested", "we use") and talk to the reader ("you").
- Vary your wording; avoid template phrases and repeated three-word phrases. It should not read as AI-written.

AVOID
- Prices and pricing tables.
- Dates and years ("in 2026", "updated for 2026").
- A numbered ranking ("1.", "#2") and question-style subheadings.
- FAQ sections, key-takeaways boxes and tables of contents.

OUTPUT
Return: title, URL slug, meta description (under 155 characters), the full page with headings, link placements marked as [link: URL], and screenshot placements marked as [screenshot: description].
Audit the listicle below against two goals: (A) getting the page CITED by AI answer engines, and (B) getting OUR BRAND NAMED in AI answers. Our brand is: [Brand].

Benchmarks come from Surfer's analysis of 201,534 self-promo listicles (Jul–Sep 2026): most-cited vs least-cited 5%, and most-named vs least-named 5%, in the same niche. They are associations, not guarantees.

Measure or estimate each item and compare it with both targets:
- Brands compared. Cited: 10+ (median 11 on top pages). Named: 2–5, us first.
- Our position on the list. Named: #1 (publisher named 38% vs 27% when not first).
- Comparison table. Cited: yes, around 30 cells. Named: optional.
- Bold verdicts, H2 per option, list items. Cited: yes. Named: neutral.
- Share of words in plain paragraphs. Cited: under 73%.
- Answer in the first lines, "who it's for", what the page covers. Cited: yes.
- Expert sources and statistics with attribution. Cited: yes.
- CTA phrases and exclamation marks. Cited: none.
- Title. Cited: "best" and a year are fine. Named: "X vs Y" or use case; no "best", no year, no number.
- Word count. Named: about 2,300 or fewer.
- Average paragraph length. Named: about 30 words or fewer; none over 100.
- Internal links. Named: 10+, about 0.8 per 100 words.
- Product images. Named: 3+.
- Prices, years and dates in the text. Named: none.
- FAQ, key takeaways, table of contents, question-style or numbered subheadings. Named: none.
- AI-written feel and repeated phrases. Named: low.
- URL slug. Named: 4 words or fewer. Both: no query parameters; Cited: no year in the URL.

Then:
1. Return a table: item | current | cited target | named target | verdict.
2. Say which goal the page currently serves better, and why, in two sentences.
3. Ask me which goal I want, or if I already said, list the 7 highest-impact changes for that goal in order.

Listicle:
[paste the page or URL text here]

Method

Where the numbers come from

All data comes from Surfer AI Tracker: answers scraped from the real interfaces of ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode.

Self-promo list
A list on a brand’s own site that compares two or more competing brands, the publisher among them.
Third-party list
A comparison list on a site that belongs to none of the listed brands.
Getting cited
The share of a report’s AI answers that cite the page as a source.
Getting named
The share of a report’s AI answers that name the page’s publisher.
Listicle share
238.6M citations, 8,677 reports, January to September 2026; the yearly trend uses the same 546 reports in every month.
Paired test
193,944 cells for own lists and 1.63M for third-party lists, each one the same report, page, prompt, engine and month, comparing answers that cite the list with answers that don’t.
Writing factors
201,534 self-promo pages in 5,162 reports, July to September 2026, 190 factors per page from the URL, HTML, text, an AI detector and an LLM content rubric. The best and worst 5% are compared inside each report.
Over time
Pages first cited between January and mid-July 2026, followed for 12 weeks.

These are associations within the same niche, not proven causes. How often a brand gets named also depends on how well known it is. Test the rules on your own pages before you roll them out.

Want this talk at your event?

2027 is open, with the first events confirmed in March.